CORRECTION: I stumbled upon the correct location tonight. This now houses Heaven Essence Candles and Spa, 7600 OH-48 (at OH-73). There is a long narrow building that has been built in front of the house and obscures the distinctive turret from the road. The garage/greenhouse structure to the side is gone, as is the arbor in the back of the property. This is definitely the same house.

Original Post: This was a challenge to find because it has been remodeled. The turret isn't nearly as prominent and they added a garage, two more dormers, and a porch but after some research, I'm certain this is right house. It's on the south side of OH-73 between Silver Lake Dr. and Township Line Rd.